Was Christ a communist?

It all depends on whether you have faith in God. The real test of faith is not how much you profess belief, vain professions of faith are worthless. If you had faith that Christ was/is God you would not care about your personal wealth since you would have faith God would make sure you were sufficiently provided for. As a Biblical reference see Matthew 6.I wouldn't worry about it too much though, many people profess to have a deep faith in God who actually don't trust him at all.

Then you believe God exists, but you don't believe in God (ie., you don't have faith in god, only his existence). But if you believe God exists in reality, and you trust that he will look after you in reality - you wouldn't need to rationalise this way. It is evidence of your lack of faith. Jesus didn't speak of workers controlling the means of production or anything that's for sure. As far as society goes he did seem to be 'give what you can, take only what you need' which is similar to the communist idea, but isn't communism itself, no.

I was suggesting that you shouldn't worry about eating tomorrow, only about eating today, if you trust that God will provide for you as per Matthew 6. Indeed, that kind of faith is rare, which is what I said. It's not a personal slight against you that you don't make gigantic unwarranted leaps of faith. Of course not. But if you trust God will provide for you, if you have faith that he will, then you need not worry about saving money. Indeed. But I was suggesting faith to mean 'trusting God will do what he says' not 'hope that God will exercise his capabilities'. Matthew 6 asks for a huge amount of faith, a foolish amount of faith in my opinion. I was just drawing the distinction between actually trusting someone (having faith) and merely believing they exist.

You should read the Bible, he starts with the promises pretty early on.

That's nice Jon, but in a thread about Christ in which I responded to a Christian who lamented falling short of Christ's standards by pointing out that few people meet the standards of faith set out in the Gospel of Matthew, maybe I was talking about the God of the Bible when I said

quote:

---

I wouldn't worry about it too much though, many people profess to have a deep faith in God who actually don't trust him at all.

---

which caused you to reply

quote:

---

Well, I believe in GOD

---

Now we have established that what I was talking about was irrelevant to you, shall I then disregard the entire discussion that followed?

---

Christ could be said to be a commune-ist, who appealed to the ultimate central authority. He was apparently against saving, pensions etc etc in some capacity, not against a decentralised economy - but probably against mega-corps. I would suggest he was proposed a needs based attitude to money, similar to the communist idea of 'From each according to his ability, to each according to his need', but that's probably where any similarities end.