My answer would be:
"You know Holy FSM (oh, you’re omniscient so I don’t really have to tell you as you know my thoughts), but here goes. Pasta and meat balls would get quite boring after a while, especially if I’m going to have it for brunch every day.
Imagine having it every day for all eternity. Not that you can imagine eating, for You don’t need to eat. But try to.
Sometimes beacon and eggs would do just fine for me."
Of course I would have to alter the answer quite considerably in the case of encountering the Jewish and/or Muslim God.