Percy writes:
I don't think that posing a speculative question implies any conclusions, but it does seem an interesting possibility that the relationship between facts and being right is a lot more tenuous than is commonly thought. We on the evolution side may believe we were convinced by the facts, but if we'd been born into a different religion or part of the country maybe we'd accept creationism and believe we were convinced by the facts. Same person, same confidence that the facts led us to our beliefs, but different and opposing beliefs.
This thread makes me think of an old Bob Dylan song, One Too Many Mornings. The last verse goes:
"It's a restless, hungry feelin' that don't do no one no good
And everything I'm a-sayin' - you can say it just as good
You're right from your side and I am right mine
We're both just one too mornings and thousand miles behind."
But we also have a popular meme in faceback, attributed to Isaac Asimov that goes something like:
- xongsmith, 5.7d