Free will vs Omniscience

What evidence? How are you able to determine via observation exactly how 'free will' works? How do you test the effect of omniscience?What I suspect is that people are comfortable with one or the other philosophical answer or one or more logical argument. But there is no evidence regarding any of this stuff.ABE:Observation suggests that we have at least the illusion of free will. So we might lean towards saying that free will exists. However, we don't have any way of simulating time machines, omniscient beings, all powerful OZ's or rocks too heavy for God to lift. So how are you concluding that the evidence is on one side or the other?Edited by NoNukes, : No reason given.

How does that address the question of whether omniscience and free will are incompatible? Omniscience apparently does not even exist. I would think such an observation would be necessary if we are going to claim that we have evidence that free will exists.

I've requoted the paragraph that drew my initial comment. There is no evidence whatsoever that whatever we experience in terms of free will exists despite God's existence, because of God's existence, or because of God's non existence. All we have is an impression of free will and a dearth of evidence about the later.I can only conclude that you mean evidence in a very loose sense. Namely that you know of facts that do not contradict your belief and that you are not aware of any that contradict it. The problem is that, the evidence is not contrary to the opposite conclusion either and thus it is not truly evidence in any strong sense.

Of course everything in a post is an opinion, but how do you calculate or estimate odds on something like this? Which simply means that I don't disagree with one or more statements in your post. Edited by NoNukes, : No reason given.