Perfectly put, Omni.
Following my deconversion, I have found myself drifting further and further towards the strong-atheism position. This may be seen as a natural "re-bound" but the fact is that the more I consider any concept of deity*, the more (philosophical and physical) contradictions I find. The rational tentativity I hold for my statement "there are no planets in the Universe where one might find that 2+2=5" is of the same order as that I hold for my statement "there are no gods".
*obvious exclusions are naturalistic "deities" such as the creator of the particular Matrix/"universe we in a test tube" we may inhabit - and such a "natural" creator is indistinguishable from a deist's demiurge/Prime Mover.