but even under the most controlled experiments, they could not reproduce organic material from inorganic.
Yes, they could. I think you are confusing organic material with organic life. Did you mean that they couldn't produce rudimentary living organisms or a full complement of organic material that might be needed for living organisms?
To claim that they could not produce organic compounds from inorganic elements is simply to deny the well documented results of the experiments.
TTFN,
WK
P.S. I'm not sure why you think experimental controls would make the creation of anything more likely, all controls tend to do is show you if your results are the products of experimental artifacts.