I think we need to back up and revisit, more carefully, the martian meteorite paper.
AC doesn't see what is wrong with his look at it. We have noted a number of things about it but he seems to have not read them and thought them through.
He clearly doesn't think there is need to reconsider his initial position on it. Perhaps we can go back over it more carefully and simply.
It is, after all, the only evidence he has supplied for his claims.