I posted the following
here.
To what degree are "information" and "design" equivalent?
Now, performing a written out piece certainly contains intelligent design and information, they being the harmonic and melodic structure.
But, then comes the improvised solo(s), or perhaps even more extreme, pieces that are entirely so called "free improvisations".
Point of reference: Someone once transcribed John Coltrane's solo from "Blue Trane", and presented it to him to play. He tried to and failed, saying that it was too hard. Yet he performed it in the first place. Did he have "intelligent design" in the creation of the solo? I say, certainly - He had the ability to do and apply design in ways that other jazz musicians were not (and still are not?) capable of doing.
Moose
Added by edit: Shameless plug of the audio links I put in message 28.
This message has been edited by minnemooseus, 12-25-2005 04:33 PM