Funk
So how do you compare a 'good' Chrsitan school vs home schooling? I actually agree with you that significantly more family involvement in schooling would be a great idea.
If I were completely redesigning school I would propose the following for primary and juniour high school:
1. Mornings: school-based learning (Christian school would be my choice of course)
Conventional academic learning
2. Afternoon: community/project/sports-based learning (optional home-based learning decidable by parent)
I really think kids spend too much time in academic classes but I also see the obvious value in having kids spend some time in this environement. Does it need to be 7 hours a day, 5 days a week for most of the year for 14 years?? Categorically, no.
The afternoon session would be run by the school (and optionally the kids could help/learn with their parents at home or in the family business) but be based on learning throuhg work. Visiting the sick, cleaning up a park, planting trees, weaving baskets etc etc. Alternatively parents could have the kid at home. I don't have a problem if the home-based learning was working for the family business or helping Mum/Dad at home in the afternoons. Others I've talked to see it as slave labour but I just don't have a problem with it and I think our society would be better if kids grew up seeing work as a part of their lives from a much younger age than they do.
Currently our kids come home from school around the time that Mum or Dad is getting dinner ready (unless your in the US and its time to work out which take-away to order). It seems crazy to me that for most of the day our kids are in the hands of the state and the TV. I'm convinced it isn't right. But I'm also equally convinced that academic learning is a fantastic leagacy that should be maintained - bu perhaps at half its level until senior high.