Yes. I will argue that it is unreasonable to dismiss any event unless or until it can be independently authenticated.
That's hardly my position. Perhaps you don't understand what is meant by "skepticism"? Skepticism is merely the position that we don't rush to judgement about something in the absence of any evidence for or against it. Not that we rush to dismiss the stuff we don't have ironclad proof for.
But, nontheless, some "experiences" are so out of the realm of probability given our current understanding of the universe. So, which is more reasonable to you:
1) Rejecting as tenatively false one single, unsubstantiated report of an experience by one person.
2) Rejecting as tenatively false the rest of our physical knowledge about the universe, which has been verified by countless experiments, on the basis of one single unsubstantiated report of an experience by one person.
“The rational and intuitive are complimentary modes of functioning of the human mind. Rational thinking is linear, focused, and analytic. It belongs to the realm of intellect, whose function it is to discriminate, measure, and categorize. Thus rational knowledge tends to be fragmented. Intuitive knowledge, on the other hand, is based on a direct, nonintellectual experience of reality arising in an expanded state of awareness.” (The Turning Point, p21)
But that's just nonsense. It's devoid of meaning. "An expanded state of consciousness?" Expanded to what? Expanded where? He's using words that sound like they mean something, but it's just the metaphysical hocus pocus words that people have used for centuries to talk about something they don't know anything about.
Capra says, “An increasing number of scientists are aware that mystical thought provides a consistent and relevant philosophical background to the theories of contemporary science, a conception of the world in which the scientific discoveries of men and women can be in perfect harmony with their spiritual aims and religious beliefs.”
What evidence does he present for these claims?
This message has been edited by AdminNosy, 04-18-2006 11:09 AM