Definatly like the last one, by a long shot.
I would have to agree that it should say "Creationism" rather than "Creation", but that is really a non-issue. Either or, the meaning is correctly defined by Michelangelo's painting.
The current one, beyond being backwards, is just over all to busy. There is that mesh of red/blue mucking up the middle and the left/right picture do not really symbolize a either side of the fight quite right.
Edited by NeuroCycle, : Spelling and a little added commentary.