Just a post to say that I've enjoyed reading this. Hopefully NJ will continue.
Obviously I'm on the wrong side of the argument to take over, but I would like to make one comment about the thread so far.
You have made the assertion that NJ's understanding of the ToE is flawed. With this in mind I think it would be prudent to clearly illustrate the willful misrepesentation by certain creationists of finds like Lucy's knee. This subject has arisen but could be more fully explored.