quote:
People have been debating about the nature of truth for thousands of years. The specialty of this forum is scientific truth. I have no trouble accepting that fossils are found in a geologic column containing rocks that can be dated by a number of methods.
But you
do have a problem with accepting anything science says regarding any of the unsupported stuff you, personally, like to believe in, like poltergeists and medical conspiracy theories.
You disregard science constantly, for exactly the same reasons creationists do.
quote:
The truths that a person might learn from life experiences, other people, spiritual experiences, meditation, etc, are of a different nature.
Aesthetic or moral "truths" are not the purview of science, but natural "truths" certainly are.
Where the "truths" derived from the above subjective sources you listed claim something about the natural world that contradicts the scientific evidence about the natural world, the subjective experiences should always be discarded in favor of the scientific.
In other words, when trying to understand the natural world, scientific evidence
always trumps subjective evidence.
quote:
To call them nothing more than subjective opinions is to grossly belittle them.
But they
are nothing but subjective opinions.
We can't test someone's personal spiritual experience, can we?
How are they useful in understanding the natural world? How do subjective opinions improve inquiry? How do we judge one person's personal "truth" to be more accurate than any other person's personal "truth". There's no way to tell.
That's not saying that people's personal "truths" aren't valuable to
them.
quote:
They should be questioned and discussed, yes. There will be some who disagree and see things differently maybe. That's fine. But are you willing to throw out the whole of philosophy and religion, which examine the nature of life and existence, because they are not as "true" as a fossil or a rock?
It isn't a matter of throwing them out.
It is a matter of understanding that they are subjective, and therefore are based upon personal opinion.