Could it be possible that what you came out of was one of the fellowships of the pseudo fold?
You know, every one of the "faithful" I talk to about my experience asks this question. "Was I
really a Christian? Or was I a
fake Christian?"
The question I ask them in return is, "if I couldn't tell the difference then, how can you tell the difference now? How do
you know that you're a real Christian?" So far I've never gotten an answer that was better than "I just know." Of course, I
just knew I was a Christian back then, and guess what? I was wrong. If I was wrong, couldn't you be wrong?
As for the evidence, not the thread for it, but many of the Biblical prophecies are simply irrefutable and have never been sensibly refuted by anyone.
I believe I'm on the record as to my feelings about "prophecy" and the problems inherent in any attempt to predict the future. These were largely figured out by the Greeks, well before the Bible.
Yah, I'm sure you'd be a tough nut to crack for Christ and Christianity as most would be here, Crashy, but hey, with God and the powerful wooing/drawing power of his mighty Spirit, anything's possible.
I'm sure it is.