Well an alternative to placentals evolving from marsupials, I guess, is that is that the marsupials split from a monotreme-like ancestor earlier than the placentals.
That might account for why both the monotremes and marsupials suckle young that seem almost embryonic. It's interesting that the female echidna (the other monotreme) develops a simple pouch in which to lay her egg. The "puggle" is not much bigger than a jellybean when hatched and is carried around in her pouch for about three months.
I do think marsupials are a more ancient lineage than placentals, but, as you say, the fossil record seems to be ambiguous on this.
Thanks for your help on this fascinating subject.
Edited by carl, : No reason given.
Edited by carl, : clarity
Edited by carl, : No reason given.
Edited by Adminnemooseus, : Put upper-case letters where they belong.