Register | Sign In


Understanding through Discussion


EvC Forum active members: 64 (9164 total)
6 online now:
Newest Member: ChatGPT
Post Volume: Total: 916,820 Year: 4,077/9,624 Month: 948/974 Week: 275/286 Day: 36/46 Hour: 1/7


Thread  Details

Email This Thread
Newer Topic | Older Topic
  
Author Topic:   Atheist attitudes.
dwise1
Member
Posts: 5950
Joined: 05-02-2006
Member Rating: 5.2


(1)
Message 77 of 121 (524007)
09-14-2009 5:48 AM
Reply to: Message 46 by kbertsche
09-12-2009 7:07 AM


Re: Benevolence
kbertsche writes:
This is not just a passive a-theistic unbelief, it is an intentionally inflammatory, militant, anti-theistic attack.
kbertsche writes:
But it is still true that "atheism" communicates a negative concept, not a positive one. The word identifies what you are without rather than what you are with.
kbertsche writes:
It is perhaps more common for an atheist to be "militant" simply due to the nature of his message.
kbersche, although I haven't been taking notes in other topics, my general impression has been that you are a reasonable person. However, in this topic, I find a need to ask you a basic question: what does your church teach you about atheists? About what atheists are. About what atheists believe and think. About why someone is an atheist. And what you are supposed to do about atheists. The reason I ask this is because decades of personal experience and of observation tells me that there is an incredibly enormous amount of misconceptions and outright bigotry directed against atheists. Why should that be?
Basically, an atheist is one who just simply does not believe in the gods. We just say "No". We've looked at the evidence and we do not find it convincing. You can go right ahead and believe what you want to, but we do not share your beliefs. I won't force my beliefs onto you, so please don't force yours onto me; ie, that classic Pharisee teaching, the Golden Rule.
Sounds reasonable, doesn't it? Only we can't simply just say "no" and practice "leben und leben lassen" ("live and let live"), because Christians, especially conservative/evangelical/fundamentalist Christians, cannot "leben lassen". The almost daily assault from Christians forces us to either hide in the shadows or stand up for ourselves, in which case we get labeled as "militants". We simply cannot accept your religion's claims and you (pl) attack us for it we defend ourselves by pointing out its flaws and so now we're "attacking" it?
My father was not a tall man, perhaps a bit shorter than average. As the smaller kid in school (1920's and 30's), he was always picked on. So in self-defense, he developed a strategy. He quickly identified the bullies and he made a point of picking fights with them. Sure they beat him up -- he pointed to his having to wear dentures as evidence of this -- , but he kept picking fights with them. Pretty soon, if they saw him walking down the street, they'd cross the street to avoid him.
Similarly, Christianity is the bully and if any atheists appear overly pugnacious, it is because they are standing up to and fighting that bully.
I became an atheist about 45 years ago when, a year after my baptism at about age 11, I decided to delve deeper into what I was supposed to believe, so I started to read the Bible. Since what I read was so unbelievable, I quickly realized that, since I couldn't believe the Bible, I couldn't be a Christian and so I left quietly and peacefully. Later reading confirmed my decision to leave. When the "Jesus Freak" movement hit circa 1970, some close friends converted and I observed fundamentalist beliefs close-up (including association with their church) and that really confirmed my earlier decision.
I have endured, especially in those earlier years, almost constant Christian attempts to proselytize me. Yet I am the militant for just saying "no" while they are the saints?
I have personally been threatened with physical violence for not sharing a Christian's beliefs. Yet I am the militant?
Every Christmas we hear conservative Christians complain loudly that they are being discriminated against because they cannot force the entire population to say "Merry Christmas". And yet we are the militants for pointing out how unreasonable and inappropriate that is?
Conservative Christians try to impose their religion upon the public schools by campaigning for school prayer, for creationism, for the posting of their particular version of the Ten Commandments (to the exclusion of the other versions), and because we oppose their efforts we are the militants and not them?
Organizations that feed from the public trough and proclaim to sponsors that they are "absolutely non-sectarian" then turn around and arbitrarily impose narrow sectarian standards (which not only were not part of the officially published rules and regulations and by-laws, but which also violated the same and which had earlier been denounced by the very same leaders imposing it) and exclude small children on that basis with extreme prejudice. When the family tries to stand up to them, they are villified in the press and the public immediately rises up in support of the organization and villify those children even worse. I have personally suffer that. I also personally know children who had been subjected to that; the courts forced the organization to allow them to participate until the case was appealed and those boys were ideal members, such that adult leaders testified that they wished all the boys were like them. And yet we, the victims, are the militants?
I have been divorced recently (do not laugh and point fingers; conservative/evangelical/fundamentalist Christian divorce rates are higher than in the general public, which is explicitly why eHarmony.com was created). A friend who's a member of a conservative Christian mega-church had repeatedly tried to fix me up with women in her singles group, even though I am deemed to be totally unsuitable for them according to their own theology as was most explicitly stated in the DivorceCare program that she had talked me into attending. There's a monthly Christian singles country dance (yes, I know, fundamentalists dancing? Some of the stories of how the church leaders have reacted, along with the fundamentalist public, are simply hilarious) that I have attended solely for the dancing, but "cruising for chicks" is completely out-of-the-picture since I am unsuitable for them and so I always do the honorable thing (remember, I am supposed to be the "militant atheist"). I mentioned this to a woman at work, a nominal Christian, whom I had also encountered one night at a general-public singles dance, and her reaction was one that I would attribute to a member of the general public:
"You're not a Christian? Why not?"
"Well, why should I be?"
"Don't give me that! Why wouldn't anyone not be a Christian?"
WTF? What kind of frakked-up attitude is that? Quite simply the frakked-up attitude that we atheists have to deal with all the frakkin' time! And you call us "militant" when your people keep throwing such crap in our faces all the time?
So then, what? People just assume that everybody's a Christian? That it's just the most natural thing? Well, I did see that in basic training, where our sergeant appeared to be a red-neck (admittedly, I'm sterotyping here, but that was the impression I had; we'll just have to reserve any judgement to be based on his actions/reactions). He assigned church-leader assignments (ie, they were the ones to march the recruits to divine services) for Protestants and Catholics, then he asked if there was anyone he had missed. One hand came up timidly. "What else is there?" "I'm Jewish." Well, hello, there are a lot more alternatives than just "Jewish".
Polls show that the bottom three religious groups in terms of public popularity are: Mormons, Muslims, and atheists. Actually, there's a fairly wide margin between Mormons and the bottom two (something like 30% opposed to 15%, but that's most likely due to the sheer size of the Osmond family (just a joke playing on the joke about the votes that Marie got while on "Dancing with the Stars"; I am a dancer, after all). Normally, atheists are the lowest group, but we're in number two slot now only because of 2001 Sep 11 (AKA "9/11").
Why? All we are saying is, "We do not believe the same that you do." What is it about that which should make us so hated? So hated that any discrimination against us is roundly cheered by the general public. That we should be the only group for which it is not only OK to discriminate, but that it is one's patriotic duty to discriminate against.
The senior Bush is reported to have said that atheists definitely should not be considered patriots, or even Americans. Well now hear this! (the Andrews Sisters started their "Don't Sit under the Apple Tree" thus) I have been a proud member of the United States Armed Forces since 1976! I was a Cold Warrior in North Dakota for five years. I currently have served for 32 years. When I finally am forced to retire at age 60 in another two years, I will have had 34 years of service. Excuse me, but a former Commander in Chief of the military believes that I am not even an American??? What frakin' kind of nonsense is that? Is that what you believe? Well, mister, you had better be ready to support such a position! This is intended as no "rug dance"*, but you have a helluva lot of 'splainin' to do!
{* FOOTNOTE: from the NavTermFAQ: "rug dance":
Quality time spent with a senior officer or NCO, usually in a very one-sided conversation. Typical topics of discussion include one's parentage and probable eventual fate. Aka 'chewing out, ass chewing, etc.'}
I am an atheist. I have been an atheist for about 45 years, about 79% of my life. I will undoubtedly remain an atheist for the remainder of my life, especially considering the role that "creation sscience" and other such blatant lies play in Christianity. I became an atheist when I realized that I could not believe what I was expected to believe, and with the addition of the blatantly false "creation science" I could not ever possibly believe the sheer and utter nonsense that Christians must believe. And because I cannot swallow such incredible nonsense, I am a militant?
kbertsche, you have seemed like a reasonable person, but I cannot help but feel that you are being prejudiced by your religion. What has your religion taught you about atheists? I've asked this of another member who is known for ignoring the inconvenient facts. In an ex-Christian site, I had once seen the citing of Bible verses about what non-believers believe. Verses that are obviously false. I had also seen creationists throw that at me (albeit without citing the source). What does your religion tell you about atheists? What are the biblical sources? How true are they, really?
Edited by dwise1, : No reason given.
Edited by dwise1, : No reason given.
Edited by dwise1, : just remembered the correct term

This message is a reply to:
 Message 46 by kbertsche, posted 09-12-2009 7:07 AM kbertsche has seen this message but not replied

Replies to this message:
 Message 92 by Lithodid-Man, posted 09-14-2009 3:08 PM dwise1 has not replied

  
Newer Topic | Older Topic
Jump to:


Copyright 2001-2023 by EvC Forum, All Rights Reserved

™ Version 4.2
Innovative software from Qwixotic © 2024