I certainly think there are some substantial flaws in your reasonings. Your position seems to be that of an old Earth creationist - The position seems to have much in common with young Earth creationism, only that you concede an old Earth. I do not think you qualify as being a variety of theistic evolutionist.
There is a theistic evolution topic I started way back in 2002, which qualifies as being in the early days of this forum. You may wish to look at and comment at
that topic.
That said, I thing your material of message 11 would better function as a new topic. I suggest you plug that material, modified as you see best, into a
Proposed New Topic. If you do such, please include a good topic title that helps define the topic theme. I foresee that such will get a quick promotion into an open debate topic.
Minnemooseus (the same person who also happens to be Adminnemooseus)