Evolution: Natural selection vs. Godly guidance

quote:

---

My theory is that evolution has and will occur in life. That this process is designed by God, for me the Roman Catholic God.

---

Shadow 71,You are in good company. One of the most prominent evolutionary biologists, Francisco Ayala, is a former Dominican priest.I assume that you believe God is omniscient, omnipotent, and benevolent.Evolution causes a lot of pain and suffering in humans and other animals. Often far more offspring are generated than can survive to reproduce. Many, especially the youngest and oldest, succumb to starvation, disease, and predation. Many of these deaths appear to be slow and excruciating. This was the case for most of human evolution and is still the case to some extent today, especially in developing countries.How do you reconcile the suffering caused by the evolutionary process with your belief in an omniscient, omnipotent, benevolent God who designed this process?SteveEdited by Stephen Push, : No reason given.

In the Biblical creation story, God's original creation was good and evil was introduced through a human failing. Attributing the design of evolution to God gives God a direct role in the infliction of suffering and situates the start of the suffering before human sin could have played any part in initiating it.Personally, I don't think there is a convincing answer to either challenge. But I would be interested in hearing Shadow 71's response, given his particular beliefs about God and evolution.