Smart, knowledgeable, articulate, etc.--qualities that apply to many, many more EvCers apply to my choices.
Dr. Adequate: Ultra-sharp analysis on almost anything expressible in words or math; disciplined and funny.
bluegenes: Deep, bold thinker; genial and deadly.
jar: Rare breadth of knowledge, hell on logical flaws; grumpy and deadly.
I could put together a dozen teams, though, without breaking a sweat and with full confidence. For example, I'd parallel that team with:
Percy: Polymath. In complete control.
Straggler: Implacable. Relentless. Drinks.
ringo: Letter for letter, the best.
In fact, I'd prefer those threesomes fight it out. I'll moderate and drink.
Dost thou think, because thou art virtuous, there shall be no more cakes and ale?
-Shakespeare
Real things always push back.
-William James