Butterflytyrant writes:
I really enjoyed reading your response. I think you have captured quite a special part of Christianity.
'Initial conditions' is an interesting topic to focus on - given how much flows from it. How many objections to Christianity find their root in jumping in part-way along, and so, suffer from poor foundations.
-
Not only is it a particularly admirable and becoming sentiment but it very neatly deals with the issue of free will puts the blame of all sin on man.
It's the saving function of sin that I find neat. Yes, there is condemnation attaching to sin but until 'the fat lady sings', a man's sin is utilized as a lever by God to try to him free him away from the clutches of his sin.
Man breaks God's law (the laws restraint is exercised through conscience) and suffers consequences (pain, distress, guilt, shame). But it's the build up this pain, the pressure it exerts on man, which is utilized by God in his attempt to bring man to salvation. Fighting fire with fire, as it were.
-
If I were not an atheist, I believe that this sort of idea would sit very well with me. It would give me quite a sense of satisfaction. It would make it easier to relate to God.
I wonder what a person does when all their objections have been neutralized?
-
Is this your personal interpretation or is this based on scripture? Is it a particular denominations position?
It's based on my own, first-hand experience of relationship God and when I glean from the pages of the bible. I don't think I'd be unique in holding to something approaching this view.
Note that I'm stripping the story clear of the harsh realities I experience in my life as a believer, in order to give the distilled, helicopter-view of what I think God's motivation is. The very last line of the U2 song, "In God's country" sums up the day-to-day reality well. It tells us of Bono experiencing being "burned by the fire of love". Sign up with God and burned you most certainly will be by the experience. It will hurt.
-
I dont have a choice about whether I believe or not. I have never had any faith. From what I understand, I will never have the chance of entry into heaven. I will never be able to seriously attempt to communicate with God. I was made this way. my hearts desire is to live as a good man. I dont break any serious laws. I love my family. I am a good citizen. But, regardless of how good my life is, if I cannot manage to make a serious attempt at talking to God. I am hellbound. This may not be how your particular variant of the church works though. Many are more flexible. Faith seems to be a requirement though.
My variant would see faith (as you appear to understand it) as something granted to you by God
after you have been saved. In other words,
after you are saved, God would supply you with the evidence you need to believe that, e.g. he exists / Christ is your saviour / the bible is the word of God / etc. Clearly that kind of faith isn't
saving faith since the above is something given to you after you have been saved.
Saving faith - the type you should be interested in - would appear to involve something that you
can form beliefs about - quite aside from your having to believe anything with a 'religious' element to it. For example:
Some people will maintain the view you currently have of yourself ("not perfect but all told, not such a bad chap - a 7 or 8 out of 10 perhaps") to the very end. An alternative is to be persuaded that the pride and selfishness that motivates so many of your thoughts and actions is a constant companion - a rabid dog that demands being fed by you all day every day. The only difference between the two types of person is that the one suppresses truths that God attempts to bring to light (and in so doing, evades the very conclusion of the rabid dog within) and the other one has given up suppressing. Stop suppressing truth and a life of shit will surely rise to the surface. Nothing is guaranteed to bring you to your knees faster than being swamped in a sea of truth about yourself
Then there's the response you form to an emptiness 'installed in you' by God. An emptiness that can't be filled with anything the world has to offer. You can attempt to fill it and pretend you are satisfied. You can try say that such emptiness is just a part of life and that you just need to grin and bear it. You can create any number of purposes and meanings for a life that insists there is meaning .. or go the nihilistic route and say there is no ultimate meaning.
Those are but two of the ways in which a person can construct their ultimate response to Gods inquiry of them. They can believe him or disbelieve him on these matters - without a requirement that they've even heard of Him.
Neat, huh?