Meldinoor was a Christian who became an agnostic during his time at EvC
Message 1 I think that the "cheer" is just a conversion of a rating given under the previous system, not a sign that Meldinoor has been around lately.
Personally I'd like to see more on your "ideological differences" and why you think that it is the skeptics who are being unreasonable.
For instance you have made it clear that you feel that any interpretation of a prophecy that results in the prophecy being considered a failure, is automatically wrong. I suppose that it qualifies as an ideological difference but it's hardly the skeptics being unreasonable there. If the best interpretation of the prophecy - by other, neutral, measures - indicates that it failed then the skeptic position is clearly reasonable, and they would be unreasonable to agree with you !