DM writes:
Let me put it this way. If enough people believe that some particular thing is possible and continue to work toward it's realization until they achieve success, anything is possible.
I am still unconvinced by 'anything is possible'.
I don't see a group of 10000 people being able to teach a goldfish to fly a jet - however much they are convinced that they can succeed.
DM writes:
I would say that his confidence in his ability was up to the task.
A climber with vertigo could fall from the tree a random number of times.
But you would argue that he has a varying amount of confidence each time?
That definitely sounds like the sharp-shooter fallacy to me.
DM writes:
...and also that it wouldn't serve as a good example for what I am trying to flesh out.
Yes.
You are standing under the tree waiting for the confident climber to succeed so that you can point at him and say "See? I was correct!" - while ignoring him when he falls.
Definitely confirmation bias.
DM writes:
If you were trying to write an equation to define the extent of all possible realities, what part would a person's attitude take in it? How much can your level of conviction expand the sphere of all possible realities?
Isn't that what
you are trying to show?
I agree that it would be greater than zero, but as I said in my previous reply, "the odds of me going to the Moon is greatly increased by me 'wishing' to go to the Moon" but I don't see our own personal confidence being able to push the boundaries of what is possible.
imh: something is either possible or it is not - but you are not likely to achieve the possible if you don't try.
But you can also achieve the possible if you don't try (i.e. accidentally inventing an artificial sweetener).
DM writes:
I see that it is a vague claim but also that there is a real and tangible effect on our reality caused solely by our attitude towards it. How big is that effect?
Confidence definitely affects our interactions with other people, but it is not always a positive effect: confidence can be viewed as arrogance.
But I still don't see it changing what is actually possible.
Hmmm...quite rambling.
Ok - let me try and draw my points into a more cohesive statement of my thoughts...
Confidence
can affect our lives (both positively and negatively).
Confidence doesn't change what is actually possible.
If someone tries to do something, then that 'something' is more likely to happen - regardless of their confidence.
But a confident person might spend longer trying to do that 'something' - increasing their chances of success.
Hopefully that makes sense.
CRYSTALS!!