The Electric Eel - more evidence against evolution

quote:

---

If natural selection is out of the equation, then only traits that can be easily arrived at through a probable combination of mutations will "jess keep cummulating."

---

Not exactly. Neutral drift will ensure that changes keep accumulating at the genetic level. And as the number of changes accumulates the probability of getting a trait which requires a particular number of mutations or more can be a lot higher than the probability of getting a particular trait.

quote:

---

Correct. I didn't get into the whole population genetics aspect of this.

---

But they mean that traits will just keep accumulating - although much slower. It also means that there is no simple probability bound that can be applied. It will depend on time, the number of genes, and the number of possible phenotypic variations within range of the genetic change that has occurred.

quote:

---

Right -- but if those traits require a large number of specific mutations (each of which are individually neutral; i.e., they only offer a selective advantage when they are all present), then it will be quite a long time before each of those specific mutations are fixed in the population, or are even all present in an organism. There is an extremely large number of possible "mutation combinations" that are never fixed in a population.

---

Sure and if you can find an example that had to have evolved in a short period of time then maybe you'll have an example. But you have to actually find one.