Sure looks to me, that a NoniNeal / Holmes 1 on 1 "Great Debate" has the potential of being a great epic battle.
Neil, it's very, very, very rarely done, but the "Great Debate" forum is designated as being for 1 on 1 debates, with each party taking a turn posting a message. In concept, it would be judged by a 3rd party moderator, but I would think we could do away with that.
Neil, Holmes - Interested in a "Great Debate"?
One of you make the proposal, in a "Suggestions" topic, if interesed. If it is to be, we can set up the ground rules in that topic. The starting of "Great Debate" topics is by admin only.
Adminnnemooseus
(full disclosure - the "non-admin" mode, minnemooseus, is very much on the side of the holmes perspective on this)
ps - For newcomers - Most of the "Great Debate" topics are from the pre-1 on 1 days, and shouldn't be viewed as examples of the "modern" "Great Debate" concept.