... the people who believe in "truth beyond logic" can't agree on what that truth is.
Yes, they do can
They sure as hell do NOT. Christians don't believe in the same "truth" as Buddhists. Catholics don't even believe the same "truth" as Protestants and fundamentalists don't believe the same "truth" as Anglicans.
Do you know what it is? Of course you do.
"I've been to Moose Jaw, now I can die." -- John Wing