Paul,
Yeah, I suppose that's open to interpretation. Haldane's paper came out half a century ago, it's been used by creationists, esp. ReMine, to attack evolutionary theory, to which a number of web-based responses have appeared, but none of these come close to identifying the true problem with the creationist use of "Haldane's dilemma," which requires a thorough understanding and careful reading of the original paper. So, of course assuming I
have figured this out, is this original or not?