riVeRrat writes:
You can't subtract .9999999.... logically. That assumes infinity has an end.
The number 0.99999... is defined as an infinite series.
If you accept that the number exists, you must accept the concept of infinity.
You are of course free to refuse this, but this would have fundemental effects on a lot of other things.
When youaccept the notation 0.9999... you accept that the concept is that the 9's are repeated an infinite number of times.
Now if you accept this or 0.9999... and 9.9999... then you must accept that
9.9999...-0.9999... =9 is meaningful
Instead of placing nine an infinite numbr of times, you subtract an infinite number of nines.
One way to prove that 0.9999... equals 1 is to use infinite series.
0.9999... is defined as the sum
9/10 + 9/100 + 9/1000 + ...
Does this sum converge on a number?
The difference from 1 is 0.1 in the first instance, then 0.01, then 0.001 etc, the difference i 1/(10^n) in the n'th instance.
Now if 1 does not equal 0.9999... then 1-0.9999... must be some number different than 0. Assume that 1 does not equal 0.9999... , then there must be difference, lets call it d, between them, that is
1-0.9999...=d, where d>0
Now we know that the difference between 1 and 0.9999... is 1/(10^n) in after n instances.
But we can make n arbitrarely large, since the sum that makes u 0.9999... is an infinete series, but then there will be a number N where 1/(10^N) is smaller than d!
But that is contrary to our claim that d>0, so we can conlude that d=0, that is 0.9999...=1!
This all hinges on the fact that 0.9999... is a sum of infinite many addends, so if you accept the notation 0.9999..., yuo must accept the conclusion that it equals 1.