quote:
Well, I just have to register my disagreement here again. I don't understand this at all. What Robin called boasting simply IS boasting, simply objectively definitionally boasting.
Then let's look at them objectively.
Given that this is a debate forum and the whole purpose for engaging in discussion here is to prove that one's own side is right and the other is wrong or vice versa if one so desires and given that this is a written forum not a visual debate; let's see how the authors of those statements "spoke" with excessive pride about ones own accomplishments, abilities, or possessions.
Boasting
To glorify oneself in speech; talk in a self-admiring way.
To speak of with excessive pride.
Now to look at them objectively, one needs to read the statements without projecting emotion onto them. Unlike a book, posts here do not come with hints as to the author's emotions. Sometimes we can discern obvious anger, but IMO, there is a certain desire behind boasting which I don't believe these posts contain. This
article describes that desire very well.
I don't know if you realize it, but boasting is geared to hurt other people. It is geared to wound somebody else--to make you stand out and them look inferior.
Now with that in mind and without adding emotion to the words, read the first quote in context which I discussed in
Message 17.
Since this is a debate forum and support for one's position is needed, the author uses his own life as an example to refute the comment. He can only speak to the facts of his own life and not anyone elses. Without project emotion, do you see the statement as an intent to hurt or to refute?
Again in
Message 41 do you read an intent to hurt or to correct a misconception?
Self-praise in and of itself is not boasting and has its place. Boasting has more of a negative intent behind it as stated above.
I don't think either writer overstated their truth to the degree that it has no basis in reality or were stated to hurt or make anyone feel inferior.
If you feel that they have, please be specific as to what statements have no basis in reality or were designed to make anyone feel inferior.
Remember stay objective, don't project.
"Peshat is what I say and derash is what you say." --Nehama Leibowitz