Are these not the same people?
No, they're not. The kidnapping guys are Islamic jihadists from Iraq and other countries.
The guys dropping mortar shells into American camps and ambushing convoys are former Iraqi soldiers.
I thought I had made it clear that these aren't the same people.
They are killing innocent Iraqi citizens and blowing up bombs in peaceful cities to try and prevent this new free government from succeeding.
Well hell, we did all those things too, only it was to topple the old government, not the new one.
I mean, if we can justify the deaths of Iraqi citizens as collateral damage to overthrow a regime, why can't they? Oh, right. Because they're not us.
Were they representing some sort of national power or alliance
Well, they are. They represent the regime that we deposed. Look, I don't think they're good guys. I don't think that what they do is good, or that the side they're on is the right one. But they're on a legitimate side. I wouldn't call a German soldier in WWII a "terrorist" just because he was on the other side.
The guys cutting off the heads are not on a legitimate "side". But the ex-military guys lobbing mortars at us are.
No, but for the life of me I cannot understand why you want to believe these terrorists are the good guys.
Oh, so in your view, everyone who isn't with us is a terrorist? When did I ever say these were the "good guys"?
Tell that to the >100 innocent Iraqi civilians that have been killed by these 'insurgents' in the last week.
I'll see your 100 innocent Iraqis, and raise you the 100,000 innocent Iraqis that
we killed.
You seem to have good intentions, but the conclusions you've come to are so evil, I just can't comprehend it.
The conclusions you come to are so littered with double-standards that I can't comprehend it. Well, actually, I can - anything the US does is Right, anything anyone else does is Right only in regards to how much we agree with it, and anyone who opposes us is not only Wrong, they're a TERRORIST.
Would you have called German soldiers in WWII "terrorists", because they were on the other side? That seems so stupid to me that I can't imagine an intelligent person would. But you might surprise me in your next post.
AbE: Look, I mean, it sucks when these ex-military insurgents lob a mortar and kill our soldiers. I hate that. But calling them "terrorists" for doing so is as stupid and immature as when a bully complains about being hit back.
This message has been edited by crashfrog, 11-15-2004 03:31 PM