Should Simple be Suspended

I am inclined to think that you are right about simple. He is actually trying. He even thinks he is making points. However, there is no evidence at all that he is capable of actually discussing anything.I don't like suspensions, so I am not going to go for that right now.I would suggest that simple be confined to the free for all or one single thread. Any deviation would be subject to suspension.The single thread should be very, very simple. It should be a chance for him/her to demonstrate that s/he can actually carry on a rational conversation. If that fails then restriction to the free for all before any actual suspension.

I like LTD Primerand Mammuthus's suggestion under members (including the possibitlity of moving both up and down).

I'd suggest a 'moving average'. Explanation if you want one. It gradually discounts old results.

Nibbles but some people aren't reliable. It is still on my todo list. However, I've been roped into some work for the karate dojo (they hit harder than you do) and the possibility of paid work too. I do want to help and want to learn.There has been a lot of other things going on with me right now too.sorry.