Wm:
How could these stumps supposedly settle in muddy YEC flood waters and end up so neatly positioned like this?TB:
I have seen it before. It is very strong evidence against the YEC flood. What geo-col era does fossil grove come from?
Fossilized tree stumps and snags are found across the "geo-col" since the mid-Paleozoic.
The oldest known tree is "Methuselah", which is 4,789 years old.
You seem to be unaware that multiple rings can form in some years?
However, dendrochronologists are aware of such complications -- such unusual behavior would give itself away with other ring features.
Also, if trees produce large numbers of extra rings per year, then it's curious that they produce them in such precise synchrony, because otherwise, there would be serious discrepancies between one tree and another.
Then it should also be remembered the tree ring record based on these trees with over laps in rings patterns of over a hundred years between trees, extends unbroken into the past for over 10,000 years.
Doubt has been cast over such linked tree-ring records by non-creationists.
Like who?
I have no problem with tree ring dating, the potential problems are small and the science is simple.
Much of the seminal work was done by one researcher whose mainly excellent work has been questioned in terms of absolute demonstration of continuity.
And where has this continuity been questioned?
And I'm sure that any errors in that original researcher's work have been corrected by now. There is a big community of tree-ring researchers; are they all dummies?
The multiple ring per year theory has also been an YEC favorite, and is equally absurd since it requires at the very least, large scale occurrence of extreme weather patterns repeated for large scales of time that no one living in those times mentioned or where effected by or shows up in any other way.
But multiple rings have been observed! And in our scenario the climate might have taken decades/centuries to settle down post flood.
Making every species of tree grow extra rings in exact synchrony, of course.
(Biblical-chronology stuff snipped)
To tell the truth, I find trees much more interesting than the details of Biblical chronologies.