I included the quotes from our chat in order that the readers might be able to better follow my train of thought and perhaps understand what I am asking better.
Well let the record stand that I felt it unnecessary of me to discipline Nemesis in any way at that particular time. The job of a moderator is to call it as they see it. I realize that folks stray from the Forum Guidelines at certain parts of their debates, but an over moderated thread is no more fun to read (with a stop sign every few posts) than an under moderated one.
Jon, your detailed and obsessively documented protest is duly noted. ;)
Add By Edit: Personally, I rather enjoy reading Jars debate with Nemesis. Jar defends himself quite well and dishes it back as well! Some arguments are more entertaining left alone.