Just reading down this thread made me laugh. You can't get rid of old Jar. Ban him, and he's causing more activity than he does when he's here.
Perhaps the ban should be shortened or removed to keep him quiet.
A week's far too long for someone who's part of the EvC furniture, anyway.
I remember having a similar clash with Buzzsaw recently when I claimed that there was no such thing as a creationist post with substance. It ended in me asking him to start a thread listing some creationist posts with substance in them.
He hasn't done it yet, and it might solve the problem if he did. Then, if anyone else makes the kind of comment that Jar and I made in the future, Buzz could just point to his list.