I think it's an admirable viewpoint, usually from neutral people such as yourself. However, in the real world arguments from religion are utterly crushed if you give any of your position away.
Look at Dawkins. He only debates "theistic evolutionists" because it is much much harder to debate a person that will not compromise his bible.
I am creationist, and my arguments do not contradict any facts.
It's all about how you see the facts, blissful. If we take the same record of animals and say that they all started with different gene pools, and now we get variation to an extent, then that fits perfectly.