I notice that every time I get a POTM nomination, people say "that's what I wanted to say!"
Obviously, I must have subconscious globe-spanning telepathic powers.
Well if anything will convince me of the existence of an immaterial sixth sense it will (ironically) be you ongoing ability to to write what I think I should have written. Your multiple nominations this month and last are well deserved.
I'm inclined to suggest that sylas (sadly missed) and RAZD are our two best posters ever.
There are a handful of others that are in my top ten and still posting too. (Rahvin, Dr A and Mod being three of them)
Indeed. I would largely agree with your choices. No matter how much I may personally agree or disagree on certain subjects with those you mention.
Percy did at one point talk about a sort of hall of fame type thing. Where the best 10 posts ever as voted for from POTM nominations were available to view. No idea how it would work in practise but the principle is a good one IMHO.