You're all (with the occasional exception of nwr) talking nonsense about math.
This prevents you from addressing an interesting question such as that raised in the OP.
It is fortunate for you that mathematics is merely an intellectual discipline rather than a religion, or I should burn most of you at the fucking stake.
Instead of being wrong about math, why don't you try being right about the OP?
Gawsh, an explanation on where and how they were wrong would've been an
interesting read.