Even in the Great Debate forum the guidelines are to be followed. While you accuse bluegenes of infractions (which I don't see) you yourself are not toeing the line. Please pull the log out of your own eye.
I've read the OP and the topic is not about bluegenes proving he has a scientific theory or that his theory is strong.
He has a theory and as I understand it, the challenge was to falsify it. You took that challenge.
Please refrain from repeating large portions of previous posts. Just link to the message.
Your verbosity is not moving the discussion forward.
quote:I disagree that it is strong, and I disagree that it is a theory, so then it is up to him to substantiate that he has a theory, with evidence, and demonstrate that it is something more than wishful thinking - ie capable of producing actual results.
Then you wrote a bad OP if the only thing you're trying to do in this discussion is prove that his statement isn't a theory.
So now bluegenes knows that the only point of this great debate is whether his statement can be considered a theory or not. Not whether his statement or theory is true or false.