Stonehenge and ID

quote:

---

Originally posted by SLP:
This has degenrated into John Paul's usual personal nit picking nonsense.

​

I am officially quitting this thread and this topic in the interests of avoiding the requisite point-by-point refutation that would ensue (and be denied, of course.).

​

You win JP.

​

Stonehemge is a prime example of how to infer Intelligent Desing in biotic reality.

​

Perfect analogy.

​

You got it.

---

Welcome to JP's world. Still up to his old tricks, I see.

quote:

---

Originally posted by John Paul:
mark24:
Regarding this claim about ID not ULTIMATELY requiring God.

​

John Paul:
This is a philosophical issue- one in which we may never get an answer. I don't deny God Created life on Earth, I just say that God isn't necessarily the only intelligent agent that could have done so. ID does not mention God, only ID critics do.

---

But what do YOU think, JP?

quote:

---

Mark24:
So it comes down to a God, that has no origin, & has existed forever, & to which IC doesn’t apply.

​

John Paul:
It is my understanding that God, by definition, is the un-Created Creator of the Universe. So your statement would be true.

---

So who is the designer? Who designed the designer?

quote:

---

Mark24:
Last (small) point, you clearly are NOT focussed on life on earth, you have mentioned Klingons, alien seeding, alien colonization, super intelligent 4th dimensional design for the 3rd dimension, most of which is in the same paragraph that you claim to be focussed on life on earth.

​

John Paul:
I guess that is what happens when I try to answer questions for 5-year olds. All of the things you mentioned were possiblities of an intelligent agent that may have brought life to Earth.

---

Ah, yes, the good old JP. I wondered how long you could last.