Straggler writes:
How can you have purpose unless you first have something capable of intent?
Well, purpose and intent are close in definition :
Dictionary.com
intent1
[in-tent]
—noun
1. something that is intended; purpose; design; intention: The original intent of the committee was to raise funds.
From Wiki:
Purpose is a result, end, mean, aim, or goal of an action intentionally undertaken,[1] or of an object being brought into use or existence, whether or not the purpose was a primary or secondary effect. It is possible that an intentional act may have multiple and hierarchisated purposes, only some of which is primary intentions while the remainder are secondary (or tertiary or more) intentions.
First attested in c.1290, from earl Old French porpos "aim, intention", purpose is related to from porposer "to put forth," from Vulgar Latin corruption of por- "forth" (Latin pro- "forth") and Old French poser "to put, place".[2] Purpose is related to the term pose used from 1374 as to "put in a certain position," or "suggest, propose, suppose, assume," a term use in Late Latin debating (c.300—c.700) from pausare "to halt, rest, pause".[3]
IMHO purpose seems to make the most sense to me. It's obviously unanswerable.
When you look in your toilet and see it empty with nothing in it
does that mean just because it's empty the toilet has no purpose? What's the definition of nothing? We use the word ALL the time. Why is there an empty toilet instead of something in it? We would say "nothing" is in it. Why is there "nothing" rather than something- because purpose isn't involved. When purpose gets involved you have crap in your toilet.
My point about the toilet is that "nothing" can be described in a lot of ways.
In order to have something,purpose is required. Without purpose, you have "nothing".
So, There is something rather than nothing because of purpose. Without purpose what is there? NOTHING.
Before you have something you need nothing. For there to be something from nothing there has to be purpose or there would always be nothing.
Edited by Chuck77, : No reason given.
Edited by Chuck77, : No reason given.