To emotionally load their case, atheists routinely blend I.D. with Creationism.
In the first place, the opponents of ID are not all atheists.
In the second place,
they're right. With very few exceptions, ID is creationism dressed up in a white lab coat and a T-shirt saying: "THIS IS NOT CREATIONISM, TRUST ME ON THIS".
If all scientists and educated faithful can come to an understanding that each deserve to believe what they individually want to believe, rejecting nothing, -- including either’s concepts of possibility or probability; and in that process reject dogma,-- the vitriol will cease and a conversation can commence.
Well, you know, one side is right and the other is wrong. Yes, you "deserve" to believe whatever you like. If you wish, you can believe that you're a giant purple anteater called Gerald. Fine. But then you want me not to disagree. Well I "deserve" to do that too.