I haven't said disagreement constitutes animosity. I also haven't said I take the animosity personally.
I guess that's not the impression I get from your posts, or from your blogging on the exchanges that happen here. (My apologies if you didn't intend that I read those; I'll stop, if that's your request.)
Let me ask you this, then, by way of trying to reach some clarity. If you take a position, and you get a reply from me that says "Faith, you're just flat-out wrong about this" is that something you take personally? If you being wrong is then ascribed to not knowing a fact that we knew, is
that what you take personally?
The *moral indignation* level here is astonishing, getting up on one's moral high horse to denounce this that or the other, really quite astonishing.
I don't see it as any higher than the indignation you display about how we're openly dismissive of the Bible and the "word of God" you believe contained therein. And I get that - your faith is so important to you that you made it your EvC username. Many of your blog posts are a full-throated defense of faith in God. If that's what you believe, it's to your credit to defend it as strongly as you can. (I disagree about the utility of faith in anything, even in God, but you're well aware.)
But just as your faith is deeply central to you, the biological sciences are deeply central to us. We're like sports fans about biology around here, why else would we be here? And the whole creationism project - the notion that untrained laymen and 14-year-olds with open Bibles can know better than a million man-hours of painstaking research into the natural world, the notion that superstition is to be placed on the same level as science, particularly in our childrens' textbooks - is just so
deeply insulting to us, and to the level of effort and expense we and our colleagues have put into being able to have even the
slightest idea of what's going on out there in the world, that yeah, we start from a position of indignation about it. You would, too. You
do, too, when the subject is the Bible.
But for whatever you think about our level of indignation, I hope you'll remember our level of
enthusiasm when it comes to being able to
answer your questions - not
rebut your statements - about biology, geology, and the other subjects we've worked a long time to know even the first thing about. The enthusiasm isn't for being able to "show off" for you, or at the prospect of winning a convert - although that's a hope. It's the enthusiasm for having the opportunity to show you the incredible
beauty of it all - a beauty you've not yet seen even a small fraction of.