I remind you of what Walt Brown forgot; there is a well established science of thermodynamics and an
extremely well established science of the properties of water. Ever hear of the Age of Steam?
Releasing that "water" (see below), dropping the pressure from thousands of psi miles below the surface to atmospheric pressure, would immediately flash it to super-superheated steam. Using what we call a "control volume" concept, think of an imaginary box buried in the earth, with the water coming in one end and the super-superheated steam coming out the other. There's nothing created or destroyed inside the box, and steam at atmospheric pressure occupies a lot more volume than liquid water, so the steam has to come out a
freakin' boatload faster than the water comes in, eroding the cr*p out of the sides of whatever it's flowing through.
Glenn Morton
did some calculations for Brown's early model (see part 3). The result is going to be about the same for any scenario you propose:
- The steam is going to come out at supersonic speed, almost certainly above escape velocity. So all the "water" will wind up out it space.
- A phenomenon called "entrainment" will remove most or all of the atmosphere along with these jets of super-superheated steam, and probably all the water on the surface of the Earth, in windstorms that make Katrina look like a butterfly burp.
- Even if you figure out a way for the water to wind up on the surface of the Earth (if you want it to fall back don't forget to convert its potential energy to heat), the mixing of the atmosphere with this steam by entrainment is going to raise the temperature and pressure at the surface of the Earth to hundreds of degrees F (or C) and tens of atmospheres.
- Noah and crew are parboiled, torn to pieces by unimaginable winds, and well on their way to the farthest reaches of the Universe. In little teeny pieces, of course.
If you read the scientific articles on this subject, you'll see that there aren't any puddles of water in the mantle. Individual water molecules are stored in hydrated minerals and crystal defects or dissolved in minerals. It doesn't come out as liquid or gaseous water spontaneously. Nor is it easy to remove
So, what about that heat problem? And the supersonic super-superheated steam? What mechanism extracted the water from its bonds? And how did the mantle get connected to the surface?
It just doesn't work.
See
Walt Brown’s Hydropate Theory for a brief critique of the even-more-ridiculous scenario Walt Brown came up with to "escape" (hee hee hee) these issues. We've already hashed a lot of this out in the now read-only
Where Did The (Great Flood) Water Come From And Where Did It Go? thread.
Edited by JonF, : No reason given.
Edited by JonF, : spelling