I'm wondering why you put this or these questions (not being a biologist of biochemist or anything like that at all) on evc and not in any scientific journal where he specialists would know what you're talking about? I'm smelling a dead rat.
I am a bit confused by your objection. Don't we want serious discussion here? I for one want to understand Vlad's claims and examine them for what they reveal. Even if they simply point to gaps in our knowledge, that discussion is useful.
Actually, what would be more useful to me, personally, would be objections to his article from the specialists on the subject. I can learn from the specific objections given by them.
To me it seems as if Vlad is trying to bypass all those thousands of specialists on the subject and then wants to shout "victory".
I'm probably missing something here, but I'm not sure I quite see what specific problem your model solves. Hey, Genomics, Phase approach has full experimental evidences in support of. Membrane approach has no such evidences. My (phase) model disproves membrane approach. However, the membrane approach is commonly accepted approach to solving the problem of the origin of life. This is my main contribution. Thanks for the answer.
So, you agree that life was not poofed into existence.
No, he didn't. At all. I do know that life isn't poofed into existence.
I can look at myself. I am the product of a "sperm" from my father and an "egg" from my mother. I wasn't poofed into existence. All those boil down to would be called chemical reactions. I'm a result of chemical reactions. So, I do know that life isn't poofed into existence. No Spooks involved.
What's his evidence that life can be poofed into existence?