Some aspects of evolution are theories, not laws. A theory is something that has been tested over and over and has not been disproven. People love to cite tests that have found something that would disprove some theories. That is horrible science. First we all know that it is easy to make errors while performing a test. We often take special measures to make sure that errors do not occure. No test that I know of can be repeated disproving the current theories. I would love to see someone who can point me to a scientific experiment that can be performed to disprove current evolution theories. There are 100's that seem to prove that it is how things were created and none that show that it isn't. We can never prove or disprove God or the heavens while on Earth but we can do our best to prove how things happen while we are here.
One way to show that the universe is older than 5000 or so years is astonomy. The laws of motion have been proven time and again and I doubt any of you believe that they are incorrect. By using simple principles of physics we can look at the stars and know with realitivly good accuracy how far that are away. We have also proven that the speed of light never changes, through both simple and complex tests. Therefor if everything just appeared by creation about 5000 years ago we would not see any stars or other objects further than about 5000 light years away, yet we do. Perhaps god created everything to appear that it was always here? If you wish to argue that there is no way to disagree but you essentially are agreeing that god created everything to appear as if it "evolved". I can cite 100+ examples that I can even prove to you through simple experiments on earth that would make everything appear to be far more than 5000 years old. But I could also argue that everything was created by God 5 minutes ago and he just implanted the memories you have of "your life" into your head. Ether things were not created or they were created with "memories" of events that obey the laws of physics that would have happened many years before things were created.
I cannot argue that God did not create the earth 5000 years ago but gave us an Earth that seems to have memories from much longer ago, but scientifically speaking everything we know points to much further back than 5000 years.