The title of this topic and the content of message 1 is such that this topic was bound to be plagued by topic drift and in general to have bits and pieces of stuff from all over. Also, the nature of the topic would seem to be conducive to having a lot of little flame wars break out.
Personally, I would have been reluctant to promote this topic from the "Proposed New Topics" forum.
That said, both the admin and non-admin mode impressions are that Crashfrog's message 36 is pretty good.
Bottom line - This topic is doomed to be a moderation problem. All that I can ask, is that the member try to put even more care into what is in their messages.
There you have it - IMO, a rather wishy-washy moderation message in a rather wishy-washy topic. Of course, there is also the possibility that Adminnemooseus is just not that bright.
Please take any responses to this message to the "General..." topic, link below.
Adminnemooseus