With the TOE gone, then we'd probably fall back to square one (well, maybe one and half). It's the place we were at for many centuries. This square being some sort of creation as an answer to our questions about life's diversity. Luckily for us, we still have a valid method for exploring and theorizing about such diversity.
The main question in my mind is: "Would the Creationists now divert their energy to use the scientific method to learn about a creation since they no longer have to attack the TOE?" I've personally never seen the matter of origins as a win or lose battle, so Creationism doesn't "win by default." They would have a tremendous amount of work to do to make any Theory of Creation the heir to the Theory of Evolution.
Are there any pieces of Evolution left? Or does it totally get wiped out? I know it's just hypothetical but it's still hard to believe EVERYTHING about the theory would vanish.
thanx
PM1K