Percy writes:
In my opinion, the only way discussions like this that try to connect science to the metaphysical or to the supernatural can only continue while the definitions of metaphysical and supernatural are kept vague. As soon as you carefully nail down the definitions there can no longer be a discussion because the conclusions are obvious and derive from the definitions.
Any discussion of course has to assume that the metaphysical exists. It seems to me then that there is likely a point where the physical and the metaphysical meet. As a theist I contend that the two meet through our consciousness, which would be outside the realm of science, but does it also connect with everything physical more directly? I would imagine that if there is a point of connection it would have to be through the very small or the very large.
As for the very small, let's assume that at some point in the future some version of string theory is proven to be correct, and that all of creation is made up of bits of energy. (That almost sounds metaphysical itself.
) Wouldn't the next area of research be to determine what it is that causes these bits of energy to exhibit their individual characteristics. If this research found that there is no physical cause for characteristics then wouldn't the assumption be made that the cause must be metaphysical?
As for the very large we can go back to something cavediver said which I found fascinating. He contends, (I sure hope I have this right), that the 4D universe that we know is a actually a projection. I thought that maybe the projector would be where we would bump up against the metaphysical but he said "no" .His contention was that science would actually be able to study the projector. The question then would be what is giving the projector its characteristics.
It is almost unbelievable how far science has come in such a short period of time. Isn't it possible, or even likely, that at some point science will come to the end of what it can learn of the physical world. At that point wouldn't we have to ask the question of what lies beyond that. What causes particles to behave as they do or what causes the projector to project what it does. If it can be ascertained that there is no physical cause then wouldn't the cause have to be metaphysical?
Everybody is entitled to my opinion.