It is certainly not a topic for here but should be discussed in another thread, Brenna.
I suggest that someone open two threads:
1) Criticisms of TalkOrigins
and
2) Criticisms of AIG and/or ICR
I'm sure that anyone making an assertion of flaws in any of these sites would enjoy laying out the details and evidence for this.
It would be interesting for the EvC community to take turns going from one of these threads to the other and see how the results compare.