RAZD,
You know that everything Gentry is saying is based on the idea that granite is an intrusive igneous rock that was melted. A 9th grade understanding of granite, and a two year old’s understanding of pegmatites.
Is that what a granite or a granitic pegmatite is?
Try Google-ing "granitization".
Here is a hint....how do you get detrital zircon grains in a granite if it was molten?
http://www.terrapub.co.jp/journals/GJ/pdf/1001/10010013.PDF
or read this:
Granitization
You can argue with Gentry on the physics, but he is dead in the water on the geology!
That’s why none of his stuff is peer reviewed in the geologic literature. Same old bait and switch. “I have a scientific paper published, of course it doesn’t say anything like what I am telling you now, but I know you are too stupid to figure that out.”
Put your money in the collection tray . . . .and just wander off in a daze.
P.S. RAZD, i really do like reading your posts, Thanks!
Edited by petrophysics1, : No reason given.
Edited by Admin, : Shorten long link.