If God doesn't see into the future (because he is 'outside' time, meaning that there is no such thing as future to see into - from his perspective) then one way to know about things that happen in (what we conceive of as) the future (because we are 'inside' time) is by observing them - now.
I understand this, I use the word "future" because it is the colloquial word we use in our temporal existence. So, we're left with two possibilities:
1) God, seeing what is happening at one time, can change something in another time in order to make a bad situation not happen, or
2) God can't affect what we call the future because it's all happening at the same time to him.
If option one is right, then we're still stuck with the situation that God knew wickedness would overrun the planet, requiring a global flood, and yet he did nothing to try and change that outcome, thereby consigning all those people to death. In my mind, that is highly unethical. We don't even let clinicians do human trials if there is a
possibility of harm to the people involved.
If option two is right, then we're left with an impotent God. One who created because he had to, and has to no way to affect the creation. In other words, we have a purely Deistic Universe, where God winds the clock and then things play out according to Natural Laws. This is hardly the God of the Bible.
I'm not sure anything went wrong with the experiment. Man was created with an ability to choose. Man choose. That's a success.
If Gods plan was to create beings who could choose to spend eternity with him or eternity without him (the fundamental basis of any good relationship being choice for/against) - and that is what he ends up with: some with him and some without him then I can't see that his plan hasn't worked according to plan.
Ok, if that was his Plan, then it was a success. People chose not to be with God. But apparantly God wasn't happy with that outcome, so he wiped everything out and hit the 'Reset' button. So, he's OK with
post facto deck stacking, but not changing the intial conditions so he wouldn't have to destroy all those lives, both human and animal. Again, that leaves us with what I would consider an unethical God.